Black Widow: Forever Red
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ☆ ☆
Black Widow: Forever Red (Black Widow, Book 1) by Margaret Stohl
A missed opportunity. 🕷️
Forever Red settles for being adequate when it could’ve been extraordinary. One of the MCU’s biggest casualties has been the loss of Natasha Romanoff’s original identity. In the comics, Black Widow is cold, calculated, and forged in the brutal discipline of the Red Room: an assassin trained to kill without hesitation. The MCU, however, softened those edges, reshaping her into a safer, more team-friendly hero. And Forever Red continues that same formula, giving us the glossy, palatable version of Natasha rather than exploring the darker complexities of her past.
This is where the disappointment lies. As a novel, Forever Red had the perfect opportunity to dive deeper than the films ever could. Books can give us a character’s inner voice in ways a movie can only imply. 💭 Instead, this story chooses familiarity. It’s fun at times, offers serviceable action scenes, quick pacing, spy-thriller beats, and that comfortable MCU-like tone. But it’s missing the cold precision and ruthless edge that shaped Natasha into who she is. It avoids the difficult questions about identity and morality, and is unwilling to confront the darker material that could have elevated it beyond just another media tie-in.
This isn’t to say Forever Red is bad, just a missed opportunity. Readers who enjoy the MCU’s lighter take on Black Widow will find more of that here. But for those hoping to finally see Natasha as the ruthless, morally compromised assassin her past suggests, this is simply a reminder of the badass origin story we’ll probably never get. 😭
